Reddit provides some insights
NO
SECRET
POLICE
 |
| Creator |
How expensive it this? What else could be funded with 1 million dollars a day? Vaccines, head start, food assistance, education aid for poor kids and disabled kids, housing the unhoused in DC could cost 4 times less.
The deployment of the national guard is a massive waste of taxpayer money.
Its actual purpose is to scare the public into submission, to accept a national gestapo-like police force.
We must ALL be brave NOW-because the alternative is far more scary.
NO
SECRET
POLICE
Commentary
Trump’s invasion of D.C. costs over $1 million a day. What could that fund instead?
Simply housing people without homes would be less expensive. That’s true across the country, including Ohio
Google AI reports this answer to the question: "Does national guard like being deployed by trump reddit".
Opinions on Reddit from National Guard members and observers suggest widespread disapproval of former President Trump's domestic deployments
. Many view these assignments as a waste of taxpayer money and military resources, disrupting their civilian jobs and family life for what they describe as "pointless" or politically motivated actions.
Common criticisms from Reddit
- Waste of money: The expense of deploying the Guard for what some perceive as a political stunt or a waste of time is a recurring point of frustration. For example, one user highlighted the high cost of Guardsmen "milling around" in Washington, D.C..
- Strain on Guardsmen: Many National Guard members have full-time civilian jobs. Posts from users on subreddits like r/nationalguard point out the disruption that unnecessary deployments can cause for their careers and families.
- Concerns over mission creep: Some Guardsmen feel they are being used for purposes outside their traditional role, which typically focuses on disaster relief and military support. A post on r/nationalguard from August 2025 indicated that some members object to being used to assist with ICE operations, which they see as a misuse of their training.
- Perception of political use: Many users, both military and civilian, express concern that Trump's deployment of the Guard in Democrat-run cities is a political power play rather than a legitimate response to a crisis. The deployments are often seen as an attempt to project a tough-on-crime image to his supporters.
- Discomfort with law enforcement role: Some Reddit users, including those identifying as military, are uncomfortable with the Guard's role in law enforcement, which they view as poorly defined and potentially unconstitutional. A California judge ruled that one such deployment was illegal, a decision that was discussed on Reddit. [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]
Differing views
While many posts are critical of the deployments, some perspectives support the action:
- Support within the military: A minority of users, particularly on subreddits like r/AskConservatives, voice support for Trump's deployments, aligning with a more conservative and militaristic stance on law and order. Some argue that the Guard's presence is necessary to maintain order in the face of civil unrest.
- State-level support: As of August 2025, some Republican-led states have voluntarily sent Guard troops to assist in Trump's operations in cities like Washington, D.C. . However, this action is also met with significant criticism on Reddit
.
Potential for escalation
Some commentators express concern over the potential for escalation and misuse of military force. In August 2025, one post on r/Military described Trump's domestic deployments as "dangerous for the military," and another user on r/AskReddit warned that the trend could "end very badly". [9, 15]
AI responses may include mistakes.
[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1mnjxjj/national_guard_members_of_reddit_what_do_you/
[3] https://www.reddit.com/r/Military/comments/1ndb8fx/national_guard_collects_unfavorable_public_input/
[7] https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/1nkkiv5/cmv_reddit_is_falling_for_trumps_obvious/
[11] https://www.reddit.com/r/NPR/comments/1l777nd/why_trumps_deployment_of_the_national_guard_to_la/
[13] https://www.reddit.com/r/Military/comments/1mybbij/trump_to_deploy_national_guard_to_19_states/
[14] https://www.reddit.com/r/Military/comments/1msfqm7/three_republicanled_states_to_send_hundreds_of/
[15] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1mnjxjj/national_guard_members_of_reddit_what_do_you/
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.